The players you've just mentioned there, Milner, Laursen and Barry were the backbone of that side and were as good as anything in the division - and indeed, better than anything we have in similar positions now even.Add in the likes of JC who was probably at his best between 2007-09, Ashley Young and solid 7/10 performers elsewhere, and I don't think anyone can make the legitimate argument that we overachieved by reaching the heady heights of 6th with the talent we had on the books.
I wouldn't agree we were massive over achievers under mon- I think we merited a top 6 place and achieved it under him and considering the money that we spent it's a tad harsh to say we over achieved- what we couldn't do was break the top but we fully merited a top 6 place.