Brad Guzan

[TimTheVillain]

Shay Given for me as well

Man City would probably sell to us

Please.

Guzan isn't good enough - too much flapping and lacks of concentration.

[UsualSuspect]

given is I think 34 so at his peak and doesn't get a sniff because of joe hart who i think is overated.

I reckon city would sell as they dont see us as a direct threat

[Simon Ward]

Another vote for Given

[Chris Smith]

Given is a good keeper, although not that great on crosses, but I'd prefer us to go for somebody with a bit more shelf life.

[Risso]

Given is a good keeper, although not that great on crosses, but I'd prefer us to go for somebody with a bit more shelf life.

He's probably got 5 or 6 decent years in him, it's not often that you get players staying at clubs for longer than that these days.

[Rip Van We Go Again]

Not being one eyed, but i'd really like us to sign Gordon Banks.

[eastie]

City have already told given he can go in the summer if he wishes , I would be more than happy with shay given as our keeper for the next few years, guzan is not good enough to be our 2nd choice .

[SoccerHQ]

I'd get Westwood in.

[eastie]

Given and Westwood !

[Chris Smith]

Given is a good keeper, although not that great on crosses, but I'd prefer us to go for somebody with a bit more shelf life.

He's probably got 5 or 6 decent years in him, it's not often that you get players staying at clubs for longer than that these days.

Or he might only have 1 or 2 decent years. Not many keepers go on as long as Fridel at the top level.

[Moorski]

Friedel will need to be replaced in the summer and not by Guzan - Samir Handanovic of Udinese would be a good option.

[WikiVilla]

I think he will end up leaving and with big Brad getting on a bit we will invest in a new keeper in the summer maybe Given if he decides not to stay at City.

Given is Arsenal bound

[pmarachi]

I would love to see Shay Given in a villa shirt...


...But I have a feeling a lot of fans want him in their shirt as well.

[pmarachi]

I think he will end up leaving and with big Brad getting on a bit we will invest in a new keeper in the summer maybe Given if he decides not to stay at City.

Given is Arsenal bound

This is all I hear about as well.

[evalast1910]

What does evalast think?

Seen him twice, and same as I said to all Hull fans when they signed him a young keeper who if the other team doesn't bang in long balls for him to catch he will do fine!

A lot of my mates who are massive Hull fans think he is doing a good job, but I honestly don't think he will make it in the top end of the prem. Will be a championship/lower prem keeper or a number two.