Hard to say.
I'd say most of the time I'd go:
Friedel
Cuellar - Collins - Dunne - Young
Albrighton - NRC - Petrov - Downing
Ashley
Gabby
Warnock for Dunne or Heskey for Gabby/Downing is equally as 'strong' (ha) IMO. Just depends on the opposition.
Dunne aside, those 11 are probably the 11 that give most for the club, though.