Players you want out

[TheSandman]

Sidwell, Carew, Warnock, Salifou and Osbourne.

Under review: Ireland, Dunne, Reo Coker, Petrov, both Youngs, Davies, Beye and Heskey.

It'll probably be worth keeping most of the second group especially as we need bodies in and any transformation should be over the longer term.

[Yeltzer]

Petrov, Davies, Beye

[eastie]

guzan
carew
sidwell
davies
petrov
heskey
and i think ashley young will go by his own choice

[saunders_heroes]

Sidwell
Warnock
Ireland

[darren woolley]

I would get rid of Sidwell, Ireland, Beye, Osbourne, Salifou, Carew, Guzan, and Warnock i dont think we will miss them that much we can replace them with better players.

[Clampy]

Unless he already has players lined up to come in January, i would'nt let go anyone until the summer apart from Osbourne and Salifou.

[Disco01]

And who said we were fickle?? What a pointless post. We should be getting behind the boys during this injury crisis.

How many of the people posting would of put Downing on their list last season?... Who may i add has been of best players so far this year!?!?

Give Ireland time he will come good, I remember people writing Milner off after his first season. Patience..... it will all come together soon.

[myf]

Carew
Heskey
Sidwell
Young
Ireland
Agbonlahor
Petrov

Gabby!  FFS He's just signed a new contract and is our best striker with a good future ahead of him.

[Leighton]

Sidwell
Davies
Carew
Osbourne
Salifou
Ashley Young (if the rumoured Spurs/Arsenal silly money links are true)
Dunne
Guzan

[gervilla]

Osbourne & Salifu....What is the point of them being here.
Sidwell....rubbish
Ireland...if he doesn't get his shit together

[john2710]

Those who fall into one or both of the following categories;

A) A player who does not have the heart to play for Aston Villa

B) A player who does not have the talent to play for Aston Villa

[Lambert and Payne]

Davies
Sidwell
Warnock
Osbourne

[N'ZMAV]

I don't want any of the first team players out until we've got players in to replace them. If we get the right players in then I believe the below players should be on their way out
Carew
Osbourne
Salifou
Sidwell
Davies
Ireland
Beye

I also think we really need to replace Petrov.

[hawkeye]

Would not make any difference
Sidwell
Carew
Ireland
Osbourne
Salifu
Only if we can get replacements
Warnock
Petrov
Dunne
Beye

[Phil from the upper holte]

Sidwell, Salifou, osborne, but I wouldn't let anyone else go unless there are replacements, and with our injuries you can't afford to get rid of players. I think realistically only carew & Sidwell will go as they are out of contract